Custom Cakes

Custom cakes start with a consultation to help you plan the perfect cake for your special occasion. In most cases, we can complete your custom cake order by telephone and email.

Once you have shared your ideas or photos with us, we can tell you what our vision for the cake is and pricing. Our chefs have meticulous attention to detail and well as different techniques and styles.

We do not have a set price list for custom cakes because each is one-of-a-kind made to meet your personal desires. Final pricing is determined based on the complexity of the design, colors and the number of guests being served.

We ask for a minimum of one week’s notice for custom cakes because we have a very busy Kitchen but the more notice you can allow, the better it is to avoid disappointment. Some popular weekends, can also sell out quickly.

  • There is a $125. minimum for all custom cake orders and prices begin at $4.00 per serving
  • Wedding Cake prices begin at $6.50 per serving
  • A 50% non-refundable deposit is required upon acceptance of our design to secure the date on our calendar
  • Edible photos or logos are an additional $12.50 to price of cake

Matthew Kirshner, is our Pastry Chef, and he graduated from the culinary program at the Art Institute of New York City. Matt has had the honor of working at some of the most prominent establishments with masterful pastry chefs from around the world; The famed Russian Tea Room, Essex House Hotel, Roger Sherman Inn, and Wave Hill Breads, are just a few.  He has been a member of the Café Xpresso team since fall 2015.

Celebration Cakes

Celebration Cakes

Café Xpresso uses the finest ingredients to make everything from scratch in our own Kitchen — our cakes, buttercreams, fillings, and ganache.

Decorations can range from simple borders or flowers to simple text with edible glitter. Our cakes are normally two layers but our Pastry Chef can create anything you can imagine — just give us a call to plan a cake for your next party or event. Cupcakes are also available from 2.25 – 3.50 each.

Please note that custom cake & cupcake orders require 3-day notice

Vanilla Cake

Vanilla Chiffon Cake, Vanilla Buttercream filling & covering with simple decoration
                8” Cake – 36.          10” Cake – 48.              12” Cake – 70.
                Serves 8-12              Serves 15-22                  Serves 25-38

Mocha Cake with Chocolate Ganache

Vanilla Cake with Mocha Buttercream & Chocolate Ganache covering the top
6” Cake – 28.                 8” Cake – 38.        10” Cake – 46.       12” Cake – 75.

Cannoli Cake

Chocolate Cake with traditional Cannoli Cream filling and Vanilla Buttercream decorated with Chocolate Chips & Cannoli Shells
6” Cake – 30.                 8” Cake – 40.        10” Cake – 50.       12” Cake – 85.

Lime Coconut Cake

Lime & Coconut Cake finished with a plain Buttercream & decorated with Lime Zest
6” Cake – 25.                 8” Cake – 36.        10” Cake – 42.       12” Cake – 72.

Flourless Chocolate Cake

Featuring both chocolate and cocoa, this cake is rich, rich, RICH! A chocolate ganache glaze takes it over the top. And, since it contains neither flour nor leavening, it’s ideal for those following a gluten-free diet.
9” Cake – 48.

Traditional Italian Cream Cake – 3 Layers

Three layers of Yellow Sponge Cake, Vanilla Pastry Cream, Chocolate Pastry Cream, Whipped Cream frosting (or Buttercream), Cherry Syrup & sliced Almonds around sides
6” Cake – 34.                 8” Cake – 56.        10” Cake – 80.       12” Cake – 112.

These are just a few of our cakes that we offer and basically, if you can imagine it, we can make it for you.

Prices subject to change based on market prices

Cake Request Form

Cake Request Form

Please complete this form and we will happily contact you regarding your cake within 3 business days. Please note that if your request is urgent and needed under a time frame, please call to speak with a team member, as they will happily assist you further.

* Required

Please Note:  Filling out this Request Form and submitting it DOES NOT constitute a Cake Order. This is a request for information only.